Not trying to be a jerk but I'm curious which tires you are looking at that are so much heavier. I've been trying to make that decision of C vs E rated and after your post, got "worried" about the additional weight. However, when I looked at a few I found these results for LT285/70R17 and LT285/75R17:
Falken AT4W
View attachment 4013
Nitto Ridge Grappler
View attachment 4014
For both of these tires, the LT285/70R17's are the same weight for C and E class. Surprisingly, for both of these tires, E weighed LESS than the C for the LT285/75R17's. I looked at K03's and the E's were 3 pounds heavier for the LT285/70R17's. Am I missing something here?
A lot of the trails in my area have jagged rocks that will jump out and grab a sidewall and have done so to me in the past. So, sidewall strength is important to me but not if it means significant compromises elsewhere. Also, while overlanding, I'll be loaded pretty heavily so that could factor in as well.