The dealership that I bought Miss Daisy from down in Georgia, Milton Martin Toyota in Gainesville, just sent me an email with a buy three get one free offer on tires, good until October 31, for $962 installed, plus tax. Looks like Miss Daisy will have Toyo Open Country ATIII’s by the end of the month, simply because of the 3 peak snow ice rating.. Black ice is a real BEOCH, and was responsible for many MVA’s when I lived in Idaho. I really don’t plan of leaving the pavement, unless the driveway coming up the mountain that we live on, washes out. Then, I think the Toyo’s would be better than the OEM Michelins, especially when it is muddy.
When I lived in Idaho, every year, every single year, hooligans in 4X4 vehicles were out first thing in the morning after we got dumped on, and by far, the most vehicles that were in the ditches were Subaru’s, and jacked up poked out 4X4’s. Why? Because they thought that they were immune to the ice. Snow wasn’t that much of a problem. Back then, unless you had had your tires siped (Les Schwab did my ‘06 Avalanche Michelins, and the initial Michelin Defenders on my ‘12 Subaru Outback), or had Blizzaks or Michelin Ice tires (my Subaru), you were at risk of sliding off. For the investment that we have in our rigs, being adequately prepared seems like a must. If I put luggage on the roof rack, it will be top notch luggage, not strapped on milk crates from the dollar store.
Whatever you decide, it is your LC, your life, your choice.