Roof Rack? Sherpa vs Gobi?

My install appointment is on July 9th. Gobi includes free local installation but Sherpa charges 2 hours 2 people, so price is essentially equal.
Are you getting the ladder with it? It was not much more for it to be included so I have it coming too. I don’t know if I want to install it and lose the back window function. I might sell it if it can’t be removed from time to time.
 
Still very happy with the Sherpa on my LC. I do like the look of the Gobi quite a bit, but quiet was a major factor in my rack purchase and it's hard for me to see how that design wouldn't be more noisy than the Sherpa. Looks taller visually, is it actually higher off the roof?
 
Are you getting the ladder with it? It was not much more for it to be included so I have it coming too. I don’t know if I want to install it and lose the back window function. I might sell it if it can’t be removed from time to time.
Found a good installation video albeit on a JEep, the ladder itself seems relatively easy to remove from it's mounting points, but those mounting pieces might take a while to get off if you need.

It was enough to convince me to get the ladder and the removable moonroof section.
 
Still very happy with the Sherpa on my LC. I do like the look of the Gobi quite a bit, but quiet was a major factor in my rack purchase and it's hard for me to see how that design wouldn't be more noisy than the Sherpa. Looks taller visually, is it actually higher off the roof?
The "stealth" model is a total of six inches high, including the box like structure, so definitely taller than the sherpa.

I don't think either one is quiet when loaded. You can find reviews discussing noise but opinions seem to vary.
 
My install appointment is on July 9th. Gobi includes free local installation but Sherpa charges 2 hours 2 people, so price is essentially equal.
That is good to know! And excited to hear your feedback. How long was the wait time from order to the July 9th? On some of the 4Runner forums, it mentions months, which definitely has me concerned for some near future use.
 
That is good to know! And excited to hear your feedback. How long was the wait time from order to the July 9th? On some of the 4Runner forums, it mentions months, which definitely has me concerned for some near future use.
Ordered on June 18th. Much better than the older reports. They also keep the optional pieces in stock.
 
Installed rack and ladder today @ Gobi Racks, local installation is currently FREE. They are still developing external molle panels for the rear windows, I may let them prototype using my LC. I'm very happy with the appearance, definitely not massive looking. Everyone at Gobi was great to work with. Measured noise at 75 mph, 70 decibels before and after, rack empty.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4368.webp
    IMG_4368.webp
    118.9 KB · Views: 349
  • IMG_4363.webp
    IMG_4363.webp
    283.6 KB · Views: 360
  • IMG_4365.webp
    IMG_4365.webp
    254 KB · Views: 357
  • IMG_4362.webp
    IMG_4362.webp
    315.4 KB · Views: 333
  • IMG_4370.webp
    IMG_4370.webp
    158.5 KB · Views: 316
Installed rack and ladder today @ Gobi Racks, local installation is currently FREE. They are still developing external molle panels for the rear windows, I may let them prototype using my LC. I'm very happy with the appearance, definitely not massive looking. Everyone at Gobi was great to work with. Measured noise at 75 mph, 70 decibels before and after, rack empty.
Very nice. Mine should be in soon. This looks great.
 
Nicely set up! That looks incredible! I will have to follow suit soon. I appreciate the update and info on the wind noise. Do you mind taking a close up of the connection points to the roof of the car as well? I'm wondering if the 1958 has the same roof mounting points are the LC LC.
 
Nicely set up! That looks incredible! I will have to follow suit soon. I appreciate the update and info on the wind noise. Do you mind taking a close up of the connection points to the roof of the car as well? I'm wondering if the 1958 has the same roof mounting points are the LC LC.
Surely it's the same up top. Four connection brackets per side. No drilling.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4378.webp
    IMG_4378.webp
    287.1 KB · Views: 322
  • IMG_4377.webp
    IMG_4377.webp
    216.5 KB · Views: 302
  • IMG_4376.webp
    IMG_4376.webp
    149.8 KB · Views: 294
  • IMG_4375.webp
    IMG_4375.webp
    184.8 KB · Views: 295
  • IMG_4374.webp
    IMG_4374.webp
    162.4 KB · Views: 314
Installed rack and ladder today @ Gobi Racks, local installation is currently FREE. They are still developing external molle panels for the rear windows, I may let them prototype using my LC. I'm very happy with the appearance, definitely not massive looking. Everyone at Gobi was great to work with. Measured noise at 75 mph, 70 decibels before and after, rack empty.
Did you find that the ladder is easily removable and placed back on with bolts? Have you missed your back window access?
 
Did you find that the ladder is easily removable and placed back on with bolts? Have you missed your back window access?
Haven't test removed the ladder but it's designed for ease of use. Not missing the rear hatch window access.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dw2
Did you find that the ladder is easily removable and placed back on with bolts? Have you missed your back window access?
The window access was a concern of mine since I heavily use it. I'm waiting for mine to get installed and will see if I really need to climb up on the roof. I found this as an alternative if I really needed the ladder.

 
I did a pretty good amount of research before I bought my Sherpa rack. I really like the functionality of it, but I actually greatly prefer the aesthetics of the Gobi you shared - I think it much better matches the classic design cues that the 250 embraces. I will probably end up replacing my Sherpa eventually just to improve the visual appearance.
Would be interested in your rack if you sell it locally.
 
Checking in with this group to see how people are liking the Gobi roof racks. I just won an iKamper Skycamp DLX tent with a bunch of other gear they had in a giveaway and torn between the looks of the Gobi and the functionality of the Sherpa Atlas. From all of my research, it seems the Sherpa is the better option for ease of RTT mounting. Have heard mixed reviews on the Gobi being a bit of a pain. Not sure I will ever get an awning but it looks like the sherpa is a winner on that front as well. Really like the look of the Gobi rack though. Any updates on the Gobi would be much appreciated! 🙏
 
Checking in with this group to see how people are liking the Gobi roof racks. I just won an iKamper Skycamp DLX tent with a bunch of other gear they had in a giveaway and torn between the looks of the Gobi and the functionality of the Sherpa Atlas. From all of my research, it seems the Sherpa is the better option for ease of RTT mounting. Have heard mixed reviews on the Gobi being a bit of a pain. Not sure I will ever get an awning but it looks like the sherpa is a winner on that front as well. Really like the look of the Gobi rack though. Any updates on the Gobi would be much appreciated! 🙏
The gobi definitely looks cool. Sometimes I wish it sat just a little lower, and I wonder if I had gone with a lower profile rack if I would be getting slightly better mileage. I think I lost a full 1-2 from the steady 20 mpg I was averaging with the nitto’s and no rack. Also, it’s probably overkill for my needs. I mounted a Starlink up there very easily. The metal mesh bottom is nice for DIY mounting or even just ratcheting down things. I’m not sure I’d want a rooftop tent on the gobi because it would be so high. Another thing I’ve realized is there’s no side panel solutions that go over the windows to mount to it from gobi yet, and I’m looking at solutions for fuel after a Colorado trip and some range anxiety. Whereas Sherpa, wescott, and others have that covered already.

It also comes with the rear ladder, but it’s just sitting in my garage because I don’t want to lose back glass function. Install was very straightforward, and I have no complaints with the quality of the rack itself.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3993.webp
    IMG_3993.webp
    519.8 KB · Views: 221
Supporting Vendors View all →
StickerFab
Back
Top Bottom