Toyota Extended Warranty Thread U.S. (negotiated price list)

[kmershly]

I spoke with Midwest Toyota today about an extended warranty.

It was refreshing to talk to a car dealer without the bull crap that is usually part of any discussion with a car dealer.

The person I spoke with was honest, forthright and asked what I was interested in, offered me a good price and the entire transaction took 10 minutes.

Anyway, I got 8 years, 125k miles for $2,400 including the 3% credit card fee.

 

[geomars]

I also had a good experience dealing with Troy Dietrich at Greenfield this month. Bought 10 years, 100k miles, for $2230. The finance person where I bought my 2025 LCLC said this price was below their cost and wouldn't go lower than $3500.

 

[Matsayz]

My dumbass found this thread after buying the warranty, $100 deposit... womp, fingers crossed to never use it anyways

 

[kmershly]

I also had a good experience dealing with Troy Dietrich at Greenfield this month. Bought 10 years, 100k miles, for $2230. The finance person where I bought my 2025 LCLC said this price was below their cost and wouldn't go lower than $3500.

In my neck of the woods, customers are not even able to buy Toyota Factory backed warranties, due to Southeast Toyota Distributorship which sells Fidelity Warranties which in turn is owned by JM Enterprises which also owns Southeast Toyota Distributorship.

So, I knew going in that I would have to buy my warranty outside of Florida.

 

[jarussell4]

Anyone has had any experience getting a decent quote in Southern Cali area. I Just purchased mine and my dealership wanted $3900. Seemed high to me, so I did not purchased teh warranty yet. Any input would be greately appreciated. San Diego to L.A. area would be fine.

 

[Bluey]

Anyone has had any experience getting a decent quote in Southern Cali area. I Just purchased mine and my dealership wanted $3900. Seemed high to me, so I did not purchased teh warranty yet. Any input would be greately appreciated. San Diego to L.A. area would be fine.

Knowing Jerry Johnson at Midwest Toyota couldn't sell to me since I live in California, I still reached out in hopes of him being able to. Well the answer hadn't changed, no. Something to do with a California law.

So I took to Google to find a dealer in CA who was competitive. Came across this post on Toyota Nation mentioning JJ at Jim Bagen Toyota in South Lake Tahoe. Turns out JJ is now the GM, he passed me over to Wayne. Wayne gave me the following quotes. I tried my best to see if he would match Jerry's prices but Wayne said no. I've sent my details over to him to begin the purchasing process for the 10/100k warranty.

8yr - 100k miles cost $1,725.00
10yr - 100k miles cost $2.330.00

Quoted from post #57 of this thread. Here you go, I hope this helps!

 

[jarussell4]

Quoted from post #57 of this thread. Here you go, I hope this helps!

Unfortunately South Lake Tahoe is over 6 hour drive from San Diego. I did read that post, but have not read any for Southerm Cali. Here in CA you have to go in person to the dealer to pay for it. I know it sucks...

 

[Ike582]

Can I assume that it's irrelevant from which dealer I buy the extended Toyota warranty? I can claim benefits from any dealer in the US? I never realized that I could shop around for the Toyota warranty independent of where I bought my LC.

 

[Blue Bear]

Anyone has had any experience getting a decent quote in Southern Cali area. I Just purchased mine and my dealership wanted $3900. Seemed high to me, so I did not purchased teh warranty yet. Any input would be greately appreciated. San Diego to L.A. area would be fine.

Unless California is different, you can

Can I assume that it's irrelevant from which dealer I buy the extended Toyota warranty? I can claim benefits from any dealer in the US? I never realized that I could shop around for the Toyota warranty independent of where I bought my LC.

In general, yes you can buy a Toyota warranty from any Toyota dealer. Evidently, some states may impose additional restrictions making it more difficult to purchase from any dealer in the US (a la California.) I live in IL, bought my LC in MO, and the warranty from a dealer in MA (Troy Dietrich).

 

[Ike582]

Unless California is different, you can

In general, yes you can buy a Toyota warranty from any Toyota dealer. Evidently, some states may impose additional restrictions making it more difficult to purchase from any dealer in the US (a la California.) I live in IL, bought my LC in MO, and the warranty from a dealer in MA (Troy Dietrich).

Fabulous, thanks. One more question if you don't mind. Is there any advantage to buying it now, versus waiting a few years when I'm close to the expiration of the original Toyota warranty?

 

[fatsocells]

Unfortunately South Lake Tahoe is over 6 hour drive from San Diego. I did read that post, but have not read any for Southerm Cali. Here in CA you have to go in person to the dealer to pay for it. I know it sucks...

You don’t have to visit the dealer physically to buy the extended warranty. I did everything via email, then hopped on a quick call to provide my CC number. Moments later he sent my receipt. A couple of weeks later I received my official docs from Toyota. FYI I live 4 hours away from Bagan Toyota.

It was a smooth and straightforward transaction with Wayne at Jim Bagan Toyota in South Lake Tahoe.

 

[kmershly]

Unless California is different, you can

In general, yes you can buy a Toyota warranty from any Toyota dealer. Evidently, some states may impose additional restrictions making it more difficult to purchase from any dealer in the US (a la California.) I live in IL, bought my LC in MO, and the warranty from a dealer in MA (Troy Dietrich).

One big caveat, in certain States covered by Southeast Toyota Distributorship (Alabama, Florida, Georgia, South Carolina and North Carolina), you cannot even buy the Toyota VSA (extended warranty), you can only buy Fidelity Extended Warranties which the dealerships in those States all claim is the same as Toyota VSA and in those States it probably is, but outside those States, it is a 3rd party warranty and a very different process to get work covered.

I declined the Fidelity Warranty and bought from Jerry Johnson as I wanted the Toyota branded VSA.

 

[DctrEvil]

Another Jerry Johnson (Midwest Toyota) customer here - Purchased $1320 Toyota Platinum VSC on 10/21/24 - includes full extension of factory warranty for 5 year/ 125K miles from with Roadside Assistance - zero deductible. Purchased LC in August '24, currently with 22K miles and on track to do about 25K miles a year so far, so chose this specific one. Happy with the deal.

 

[spamrisk]

A customer of Jerry’s too. 7/125 for me. $ 1920 all in on my 2025 lc. Dealer wanted $3k for 5/75 or something outrageous (that was their “you’re a good customer special discount”) like that. Usually don’t purchase warranties but with the fair price they offered I went with it. Thx to this forum for giving fair options where it’s NOT a one sided deal!