Let's bring some sanity into this Toyota fan boy discussion.
I have been driving for over 40 years and I have owned:
- 9 Toyotas
- 1 Lexus
- 4 Renaults
- 1 BMW
- 2 Chevrolets
- 2 Volkswagens
- 2 Fords
- 1 Suzuki
- 1 Nissan
- 1 KIA
(We have always been a 2-3 cars household)
All manufacturers make good and bad cars, and difference between the perceived "reliable" and "unreliable" cars is very small.
In my experience the most reliable vehicles I have owned were the 2 VWs and a couple of the Toyotas. They never gave me any problems.
All 4 Renault were also quite reliable as well as both Chevrolets, both Fords, the KIA and the Suzuki.
The BMW was by far the nicest to drive and the reliability was about average, but below the vehicles listed above.
The Nissan was below average, too.
As for the Toyotas, most were average, two were very good and two were actually the least reliable cars I have ever owned, with serious mechanical problems. My wife's RAV4 had two (!) transfer cases and the transmission replaced before it reached 42k miles. And the other was an FJ Cruiser that had several issues, including transfer case failure around 50k miles and driver's seat replacement at about 20k miles because the seat adjustment mechanism failed.
These two Toyotas were the only vehicles with serious drivetrain problems. As for the other vehicles, all the problems were minor and easy to fix: things like an alternator, a relay, a starter or a door lock actuator, but never an engine or a transmission.
Honestly, in my personal experience Toyota really doesn't stand out in terms of reliability, and is below average when it comes to driving experience. And Toyota's customer service is probably the worst of all the brands I have owned. Toyota dealers and Toyota corporate behave as if one should be grateful for driving a Toyota and that they are doing you a huge favor by allowing you to buy one. On the other hand, VW's and Renault's customer service were outstanding.
So for those who will ask why I keep owning Toyotas, the answer is that due to some odd financial arrangement I can get them very cheap, we'll below what I would have to pay for other brands. The only downside is that I cannot resell them and have to keep them for at least 3 years.
If it wasn't for the special financial arrangement and based on my experience with all these different brands I wouldn't be driving a Toyota as most other brands are nicer to drive, have better customer service and there really isn't any significant reliability difference. At least this has been my experience.